Wednesday, September 23, 2015

Twins Versus Siblings, Where’s The Line?

Biology concepts – twins, genetic linkage, racial phenotypes, skin pigmentation, single nucleotide polymorphism,  random assortment, discordant race twins


A great story came out this past July about a twin Earth. Well, almost. In looking for exoplanets, the holy grail is a planet that looks a lot like Earth. It should have the possibility of liquid water, it should be about the same size so that the gravity would be similar, and it should be rocky, so people would have a place to stand.


The movie Prometheus had a very twin-like planet that apparently
had life on it that seeded and reseeded Earth with life – then was
going to destroy it. This was the prequel to the Alien movies. We
just found a close twin to Earth, but there’s no indication of disco
balls there. And traveling our fastest right now, it would take 25
million years to get there. Maybe disco will be dead by then.
The Kepler Space Telescope team found our closest twin yet, and she’s only 1400 light years away (8.23 x 1015 miles). Kepler-452b is 1.6 times as large as Earth when most of the exoplanets are 6-20 times the size of Earth. It has about twice the gravity - still in a decent range, but will drive every teenage girl nuts. She’s going to weigh twice as much!

The planet is right on the edge of the habitable zone where liquid water would be possible, and she is about 6 billion years old (Earth is 4.55 billion years old). Kepler-452b has an orbit time of 384 days. Everybody will be just a bit younger, so now we have the women back on board. The star it orbits is of the same type as our Sun (G2) and gives off about 10% more energy – tanning will be easy. That’s about the best you’re going to do when looking for a twin planet. Astronomers aren’t sure, but they suspect that it has a rocky core and surface, so building shopping malls will be easy – thank goodness.

This is the best possibility science has found yet for a planet that might harbor life that looks like us. It’s age means that it's had time to evolve life to a significant stage. And it could be a second home to us if we keep destroying our world and we learn how to travel that far. On the other hand, it could be a gas planet and have a toxic atmosphere so that nothing like us could live there. Could there be twin species out there staring at us through a big telescope?

This got me to thinking – how do you define twins? Monozygotic is easy, they’re conceived at one time from one egg and one male gamete. But what about dizygotic twins? They’re no more closely related as any two siblings, so what makes them twins? Is it because they were conceived in one attempt? Is it because they have the same mother and father? Is it because they are born at the same time?


There are 600 proteins used to make and distribute melanin
in skin, hair and eyes. There are at least 50 genes that control
skin pigmentation to some degree. Each has many different
versions (alleles). A new forensics test can predict accurately
how dark a person’s skin is just by testing any DNA
from the individual.
Well today we’re going to begin to redefine your idea of dizygotic twins. Almost everything you think makes a person a twin has an exception. Let’s start with an easy one. Dizygotic twins are of the same race, or at least they look like it ----maybe, no.

If one child is fair skinned, blue eyed, and straight haired and another is brown skinned, brown eyed and woolly haired, can they possibly be twins? The answer may surprise you.

Some of the heritable systems that control obvious “racial” phenotypes like skin color or hair texture can be quite complex. Many genes that contribute to the variability in skin pigmentation – there are over 600 proteins that work together in melanosome (see this post) production of the eumelanin that colors the skin brown.

One gene, solute carrier family protein member 5 (SLC24A5) has a significant effect on whether a person will be light or dark skinned. Its gene has only two known alleles, one confers dark skin and the other light. Dang near 100% of northern European descent have the light skinned allele of SLC24A5.

But despite the strong contribution of this gene and a close family member (SLC45A2), SLC24A5 accounts for only 30% of the pigmentation difference between Western Africans and Northern Europeans, so many other genes are also involved.  One such gene product is the melanocortin 1 receptor (MC1R). There are several variant alleles, some of which have no function and result in much lighter skin color.


This chart is simplified greatly, because we know now that
there are many genes that control eye color. OCA2 controls
brown to some degree, the B= brown, dominant allele. The
gey gene works in blue and green coloring. If you have just
one B, your eyes will still be brown.
It is believed that when humans left Africa for more northerly latitudes, there was less genetic pressure to keep a functional MC1R for protection from the solar radiation. The non-functional alleles came from genetic drift (lack of pressure) and became predominant in the northern populations – light skin.

The key is that different alleles for all the skin pigmentation genes get passed on and it is the combination of alleles in each male and female gamete that join which determine the skin color of that individual.

Because so many genes with so many alleles all work together to control skin coloration, most biracial kids turn out to be a shade somewhere between mom and dad; the odds of getting a certain set of alleles to look more like one than the other are low. But it does happen. Now add in the chances of having twins (about 1 in 50 or so), and then multiply all this together with the odds that both twins would receive a set of alleles to code for a very dark skin pigmentation and that the other twin would get a complete set for very light skin.


Here are Lucy and Maria Alymer (left) and Lauren and
Hayleigh Spooner-Durant. They are sets of dizygotic twins.
Makes you ponder the genetic linkage of hair texture and hair,
skin and eye color. It also makes you wonder if it might be X
linked, all the sets I have seen are girl/girl.
Like skin pigmentation, eye color is controlled by several genes, some of which overlap with skin color regulation. Single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs, single base changes in gene sequences that might lead to small or large changes in function) are known in the OCA2 and HERC2 genes are known to control blue eye coloration, it being the recessive trait where loss of function leads to the lighter color.

Northern Europeans have several possible eye colors – blue, brown, green, hazel, while people of African descent almost always show dark brown irises. The alleles for variant eye color (like skin) have evolved only recently and are recessive. The dominant alleles are those for dark skin and dark eyes.

Then there are the genes that control hair texture. By in large, the shape of the hair follicle regulates the coil of the hair. The flatter the follicle, the tighter the coil of the hair. On the other hand, the diameter of the follicle determines how thick the hair is. Africans universally have tight coil and thick hairs. They make enough oils but it's hard to coat all the way down the hair shaft due to the coils.

With random assortment in the production of male and female gamete cells (see this post), the chances are high that two eggs or two male gametes will have different alleles for skin color, hair texture, and eye color. In biracial couples, the chances are high that since these phenotypes are controlled by several genes each, the combination of alleles will leave a child somewhere in the middle for each trait. But something called genetic linkage can skew the chances of some combinations of traits showing up together.


This is Kian and Remee Hogdson. They are from the UK, just
like the two sets above. Will more interacial couples and
babies strengthen the species by increasing diversity, or would
reproductive isolation like most often happens (you marry
someone who looks like yourself) allow for divergence and the
ability of one group to have the best chance of surviving some
evolutionary catastrophe? I don’t know.
The relationship between skin, eye, and hair color makes sense. Some of the same genes that contribute to skin pigmentation are also involved in iris pigmentation. Alleles that would make skin dark go along with alleles that promote dark eye color, so it is not surprising to me that people of Africa descent have a combination of dark skin, dark irises, and dark hair.

What I wonder about is the linkage between skin pigmentation and hair texture. People of African descent almost universally have tightly curled, ie. woolly, hair. Why are the dark skin and the woolly haired so strongly associated with one another? If the genes are located close to on another on the same chromosome or if one gene affects the other, then they might be inherited as a package – this is the essence of genetic linkage. The closer two genes are on a chromosome, the more likely that those alleles will always show up together.

There’s no evidence (yet) that hair texture and skin color genes are linked to one another; in fact, the many genes involved in these traits makes linkage less likely. But don’t tell that to Kian and Remee Hodgson. Despite the long odds (maybe one in 2 million), there have been several cases of discordant race twins recently, mostly in the UK (see pictures above). Lucy and Maria Alymer, as well as Lauren and Hayleigh Spooner-Durant. Looking at their pictures, it sure seems that these traits are inherited as a package.


There is no absolute when it comes to phenotypes and race.
There are blue-eyed Africans, and Europeans with kinky hair
(ask your parents who Bob Ross was, with his happy little trees).
It goes the other way as well, some Africans can have
straight or wavy hair. 
On the other hand, a set of black and white twins born in 2010 were ascribed to one twin having inherited a form of oculocutaneous albinism. One twin had white skin with red hair and red irises, while the other twin had dark skin, dark hair and looked like the parents. So, different looking twins doesn’t always mean a strange allele package.

If these exceptions weren’t weird enough, how about some exceptions to the sets of traits? Woolly hair syndrome is what it's called when fair skinned people have tightly coiled hair like people of African descent. There are blue-eyed Africans – usually from a spontaneous mutation in the OCA2 gene, or from a disease like Waardenburg syndrome, or perhaps they have Caucasian ancestors on both sides of the family (because blue eyes are recessive). There are also African tribes with high percentages of people with straight or wavy hair.

Just remember, we’re all in this together and we’re all playing with the same genes. It’s just the combination of alleles you get that will tell the tale. With the advent of more interracial couples, we are moving toward a time when all alleles will be equally possible in all people. This won’t mean everyone will be the same color, just that more shades of pigmentation will be possible in each baby.

Next week we take on another possible definition of twinning – are all twin babies born at the same time?



Sturm, R., Duffy, D., Zhao, Z., Leite, F., Stark, M., Hayward, N., Martin, N., & Montgomery, G. (2008). A Single SNP in an Evolutionary Conserved Region within Intron 86 of the HERC2 Gene Determines Human Blue-Brown Eye Color The American Journal of Human Genetics, 82 (2), 424-431 DOI: 10.1016/j.ajhg.2007.11.005

Duffy DL, Montgomery GW, Chen W, Zhao ZZ, Le L, James MR, Hayward NK, Martin NG, & Sturm RA (2007). A three-single-nucleotide polymorphism haplotype in intron 1 of OCA2 explains most human eye-color variation. American journal of human genetics, 80 (2), 241-52 PMID: 17236130

Maroñas, O., Phillips, C., Söchtig, J., Gomez-Tato, A., Cruz, R., Alvarez-Dios, J., de Cal, M., Ruiz, Y., Fondevila, M., Carracedo, �., & Lareu, M. (2014). Development of a forensic skin colour predictive test Forensic Science International: Genetics, 13, 34-44 DOI: 10.1016/j.fsigen.2014.06.017

Gerstenblith MR, Goldstein AM, Fargnoli MC, Peris K, & Landi MT (2007). Comprehensive evaluation of allele frequency differences of MC1R variants across populations. Human mutation, 28 (5), 495-505 PMID: 17279550